Craig T. Nelson | pinartarhan.com

The Company Men starring Ben Affleck, Tommy Lee Jones, Chris Cooper, Maria Bello & Kevin Costner. Image via prlog.org

&nbsp

Bobby Walker (Ben Affleck) has really made it: he is a white-collar that makes 120K a year+ bonuses, he drives a Porsche, goes golfing, has a beautiful house he can barely afford as well as a wife and 2 kids.

Phil Woodward (Chris Cooper) is pushing 60, and has climbed up considerably well in the corporate ladder.

Gene McClary (Tommy Lee Jones) is in the board of directors of the company both Bobby and Phil are working for, and is leading a very comfortable lifestyle.

However when a economic crisis hits the US, James Salinger (Craig T. Nelson), the CEO of their company, starts letting a lot of men go, starting with Bobby, who has been one of Gene’s favorite employees. Bobby finds that he hasn’t exactly saved money, and the expenses seem too much for an unemployed man to cover. He also realizes that his 12-year-experience doesn’t mean much in a competitive marketplace where much younger guys are willing to work for less. As he begrudgingly gets unemployment assistance, the CEO lets more people go and the company starts getting out of Gene’s control. Phil is also fired, and Gene’s reaction doesn’t reflect well on his affair with the head of human resources, Sally Wilcox (Maria Bello).

Bobby’s wife gets back to work, and he unwillingly accepts the job offer of Jack (Kevin Costner), his wife’s brother. He doesn’t enjoy having to work in construction under a man who believes all corporate white-collars are unworthy of their salaries, but he doesn’t have any other options left. Phil takes it much, much harder and Gene struggles with his values and keeps disapproving James’ actions…until Sally has to fire him as well.

3 former company men all get depressed and furious, and they all come up different solutions to their problems…

Thoughts, Other Criticisms and Endnote

The Company Men is a slow-paced, albeit effective drama about how much people give to their careers, what these careers demand and how they cope when the company they have built their careers at suddenly lets them go. It is realistic, a little sad and does offer some quite obvious (yet valuable) life lessons.

While some viewers have criticized the movie for aiming to make us feel sorry about a bunch of rich white guys, they are actually missing the point. The movie is about how the lives of 3 white collar men turn upside down. What, because they earned much more money than the average movie-goer, their story is not worth telling? Would those viewers not be crushed if the careers they gave their life to/depended upon/defined themselves with were taken away from them?

With Ben Affleck’s character, he suddenly finds himself without any money- with a family to take care of, his frustration is understandable. He wasn’t always upper middle class. And you know the last job Jim Carrey would want on earth? It is being a custodian. Not because he looks down on the profession. It is because he was actually broke, and worked as a custodian. It is understandable that Afflec’s Bobby doesn’t want to do construction work until he absolutely has to….

With Chris Cooper, it is how he defines himself. He is from a generation where people gave their lives to one company. He doesn’t know what to do. Sure, it is sad, and a little pathetic maybe. But his job is all he knows…

With Tommy Lee Jones, it is the betrayal of a friend, the lack of empathy in his friend and how values millions over the lives of other people…

So of course you can criticize the characters for caring too much about one company, the course of one career. You can judge them for not being prepared. But it is hard to prepare for a big downhill, if things went on very smoothly for a very long time.

So, no, this movie is not about 3 rich guys who suddenly find themselves penniless. The only guy who finds himself penniless is the one who wasn’t rich to begin with. The Company Men is about how much value we place on our careers/jobs, how precaution matters, how we should have more than just our jobs/education to define us and how life really requires us to have a back-up plan. It may not be the most original story around, but guess what- my father experienced what Affleck went through. He went through what Cooper went through too, although thankfully he got over it just fine because my mom has always been great with managing money. I find it hard to believe that people who really watched this movie-from beginning to end- couldn’t find something they could relate to.

Some complained that the women in the film weren’t depicted in the best light. At best, they had been loyal wives who picked their husband’s career over theirs. At worst, they were either successful businesswomen who didn’t mind sleeping with married men or materialistic women who just lived through their husband’s wealth. But come on…Not all movies have to give us amazing female characters. There are a lot of women who prioritize their husband’s money, their career and just sit at home and look after the kids. It’s their choice. And just because I am not like that, I am not going to give up on a perfectly good movie because the female characters aren’t that great. And look at the title of the movie…Does it look like it’ll be an effective study of the modern woman?

Is this a movie you absolutely have to see? No. It is good, emotional and has good acting. Sure, you can ignore it. After all, it is not life-altering. It is not mind-blowing. It doesn’t reinvent anything. And it’s more about facing reality than being entertained. But it is solid, the actors are great and it doesn’t make you regret you saw it. Rated at 6.8 on IMDB, it all depends on how interested you are in the core story. Because it is delivered well.

Written and directed by John Wells.

Margaret Tate (Sandra Bullock) is a beautiful, successful and workaholic editor at a big publishing firm in New York. However to her co-workers, she is the absolute bitch from hell; especially to her long-suffering assistant Andew Paxton (Ryan Reynolds). He has been working day and night, putting in weekends so that he can be an editor himself. Unfortunately, this goal requires him being Margaret’s slave.

However Andrew gets the upper hand when Margaret is facing the problem of deportation as she is Canadian and her visa has expired. She finds the perfect solution: she will marry Andrew and keep her job and because she is staying in the firm, he won’t be fired. The unwilling Andrew gets a bigger shock when the immigration officer Mr. Gilbertson (Dennis O’ Hare) informs them that a fraud marriage will result in a prison sentence of 3 years and a fine about $250,000. So Andrew blackmails his way into an immediate promotion and they go to Alaska together to give Andrew’s family the good news. Of course they have to pretend they are in love and keep “the fraud” secret. So the grandmother Annie (Betty White) and mother Grace (Mary Steenburgen) are more than surprised when Andrew brings home the “absolute evil bitch”. However they are happy to have Andrew back and they are willing to welcome Margaret into the family. But the father of the house (Craig T. Nelson) is already bitter because Andrew didn’t take over the family business and moved to New York to be an editor’s assistant, a job area he doesn’t respect and a passion he doesn’t understand. Of course trouble doesn’t end there. Mr. Gilbertson isn’t willing to leave them alone and the more Margaret gets to know the family, the more she gets to love them. And Andrew starts seeing a whole new side to Margaret. But how is a business deal is supposed to work when feelings get involved?

The Proposal is one charming and hilarious romantic comedy. And don’t get the “romantic” part in the romantic comedy to cloud your judgment, as the movie does a wonderful job of making you laugh. The cast is marvelous, especially Betty White. Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds have great chemistry and comedic timing together. This movie is 85-90% comedy. Note that gorgeous Malin Akerman also co-stars. She plays Gertrude, Andrew’s high school sweetheart.

Written by Pete Chiarelli and directed by Anne Fletcher. Sandra Bullock was nominated for Best Actress in a Comedy at the Golden Globes for her role. Rated at 6.7 on IMDB. All around fun. 7/10 from me.

Favorite Scenes:

* any scene with the dog Kevin – especially the “eagle dance”

*The bathroom scene- the naked “clash”

*Sandra Bullock and Betty White chanting in the forest together

Favorite Lines:

– on the clash – Margaret blames it on the dog blocking her way.

Andrew: Oh- I barely made my with my life out there.

and pretty much anything during the ending credits.

Other Posts Featuring Ryan Reynolds

Foolproof starring Ryan Reynolds

The Nines starring Ryan Reynolds and Hope Davis

20 Tall Actors from Hollywood

Other Posts on Sandra Bullock

While You Were Sleeping starring Bill Pullman and Sandra Bullock

The Lake House starring Sandra Bullock and Keanu Reeves

The Blind Side starring Sandra Bullock

Also on Ben Affleck:

Also on Maria Bello:

Also on Kevin Costner: