You are here: Home > Movies and Actors > Reviews of 4 Nicholas Sparks Movie Adaptations: A Walk to Remember, Nights in Rodanthe, Message in a Bottle and The Notebook

Reviews of 4 Nicholas Sparks Movie Adaptations: A Walk to Remember, Nights in Rodanthe, Message in a Bottle and The Notebook

Share

SPOILERS!

I really like the 4 movies I mentioned above. They feature talented and beautiful stars, they are beautifully directed and they have been adapted from the works of the same author: Nicholas Sparks. I have never read him, and I am not exactly tempted to.  Although I am a romantic who likes her emotional stories, I am also big fan of escapism- I like the movies that take us to a more beautiful place. But Sparks does seem to like giving this feeling and then abrubtly taking it away.

Let’s go over the movies shortly, shall we?

*Message in a Bottle (1999)

Starring: Kevin Costner, Robin Wright-Penn

message-in-a-bottle-posters

Kevin Costner and Robin Wright-Penn in Message in a Bottle. Co-starring Paul Newman as Costner's dad.

Garret Blake (Costner) is a sailor and he builds boats for a living. He is yet to overcome his beloved wife’s death. He has written love letters to her and sent them out into the open sea.

Theresa (Penn) finds the letters on the beach and decides to find the writer. She is a single mother- and having previously been cheated on, she wants to find the man who is so in love with his wife. And being a journalist, she does convince her boss that it is a business trip.

When she does get to meet Garret, she of course can’t tell him the truth. Garret is attracted to this fragile and beautiful stranger- the first woman he has ever felt close to after the loss of his wife. Theresa was already in love with the idea of the man. Real Garret only exceeded her expectations…

So two previously hurt people find love again. It is beautiful. We sail, laugh and cry with them. Of course they have obstacles. Theresa lives in the city and has a son, plus she can’t really get over feeling that he will never love her the way that he loved his wife…And he is bound to find out how Theresa got to find him… Couldn’t we have just sorted out these and moved along? Couldn’t we have let these likable characters be happy? Well, I could… But Nick had other ideas. It is a lovely story. But the truth is if you are looking for realism, why would you watch this in the first place? How many people love so unconditionally like that? How many people love like that for the second time? (in Theresa’s case-Garret might be her only true love) And what are the odds that they are going to look like Wright-Penn and most of all- Kevin Costner? So if we have let go all of the cynism and stretched our imaginations so far, why not let us have a happy ending?

message_in_a_bottle_ver3

* A Walk to Remember (2002)

Starring: Shane West, Mandy Moore

17911633_406pxA_Walk_To_Remember_Poster

Shane West and Mandy Moore in A Walk to Remember

Yeah, of course you have all heard it before. Bad Boy. Good Girl. They fall in love. It turns out Bad Boy is actually a great guy- given the faith and chance. But…Before the but, let’s describe the good and bad in this movie.

The bad boy is Landon Carter (Shane West). He is your typical angry and popular teenagers. His grades are low, the headmaster isn’t too fond of him, the girls love him,hates his father who left him and his mom for another woman and of course he thinks being unpopular is worse than death.

Cool, hot and bad

Shane's character: Cool, hot and bad.

But one day he gets into trouble he can’t get out of, and the headmaster has the pleasure to make him do everything he despises. As if it is not enough that the trouble gave him temporary crutches…

Jamie is everything Landon isn’t. Nice, unpopular,uncool,a religious jamie%20sullivanvirgin.They have known and despised each other for a long time. But now, Landon has to play the lead in the theater group,tutor kids with learning problems- basically has to turn to Jamie for help. At some point though, they get to be less judgemental about each other and even get to be some sort of friends.

Landon goes for an impulsive, unscripted kiss

Landon goes for an impulsive, unscripted kiss

However Landon doesn’t seem to be ready to leave his previous lifestyle and lets his friends believe he is definitely not friends with Jamie-right in front of her. At the play night, Landon will realize not only he misses Jamie’s friendship, but that he is attracted to her…

Everyone is shocked- his friends, Jamie, him,…Now he has to prove to Jamie that he is not the bad-ass she thinks he is. He gets the chance when his friends play a horrible joke on Jamie and he sticks with Jamie, leaving his group. He persuades Jamie and her dad (the priest) to go on a date. OK- since I really like this movie, I can gladly explain why the clichés do not bother me:

1) Jamie isn’t quite an ugly duckling. For one thing, she is not ugly, just plain. For two, She just doesn’t believe in expressing herself with clothes. She sings and shows her beauty at the play and yet doesn’t maintain the glamorous attitude afterwards.

2) Landon only hates his father (played by David Lee Smith) – he is actually helping out his mom at home.

3) Jamie shows him just like he sees her as a loser, she does see him as loser who will have nothing in life after high school. And as they are forced to spend time together, they realize that maybe things aren’t so black and white…

After this, it is so romantic. They go on dates, they have great fun together- Landon respects Jamie’s boundaires.

31509189_bff8dc9208

OK. So the bad boy turning to the romantic in every girl's dream is a bit of a strecth. But hey, movies are for escapism. And where else are we going to see this kind of character looking like Shane West) anyway?

Perfect. Landon turns out from the guy who you would wanna have sex with yet wouldn’t be able to have a relationship from to the most amazing boyfriend on the planet. Does it last? Of course not. Jamie tells Landon one big secret that turns his life upside down. She has cancer. She has had it for a long time. And she is not responding to treatment. Landon is crushed. He is bitter and he is furious. I would be to. You fall in love head over heels and to find out you are going to lose that person forever? Life’s way of giving you the bird. He even asks for his dad’s help. But he can’t go around being angry at Jamie, right? She might die anytime…

shane-west103

So he sticks by her bed. He tries to do everything she has ever wanted. He makes her happy. It is great. Seriously. Previous asshole is the soulmate we have been dreaming about. And he looks like Shane West. Too unrealistic. So let’s kill the girl and make it even…

A-walk-to-remember-a-walk-to-remember-692352_962_716

A collage of A Walk to Remember Scenes

 

* The Notebook (2004)

Starring: Ryan Gosling, Rachel McAdams

The Notebook poster: Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams

Two time frames:

Present, retirement home. We see the interactions with two old people (played by Gena Rowlands and James Garner).

Past, a rich girl called Allie (McAdams) falling for the poor boy Noah (Gosling). They are mad about each other. They fight a lot but they can’t and won’t stay away from each other.

Allie and Noah

Allie and Noah

notebook

Somehow her mother manages to drive a wedge, yet neither of them forgets. We get to hear their story from the notebook the old guy in the retirement home is reading to the old woman. She loves the story of these two lovers who cross paths years later- when his name is on the newspapers for a lovely restoration he has made. She is about to be engaged to a guy (played by James Marsden) she actually loves. But she can’t resist the urge to talk to him. The house belongs to both their pasts. So she visits him. They get to let out their feelings, and face why they were driven apart. Then Noah wants her to leave her fiancé- she is torn. But her feelings for Noah are just too strong…

It is beautiful. They stayed together. They had lovely children. They are still togeter- in the retirement home. You see, the guy is Noah- reading the story to Allie. How can you not be touched by that? Where’s the drama, you ask? Noah has to read the story to her over and over again because she has Alzheimer’s and she has no clue who he is. She flashes and remembers maybe for a minute- and then she forgets again…

Lovely,touching and tragic. It might be how it happens in real life. We don’t get to be in love forever, I get that. But sometimes I feel like the sad parts are thrown in just to make you cry. I love the movie, just like I love the ones mentioned above. Still, couldn’t have Allie remembered? Couldn’t she have a more managable disease and have her memory??? Of course, it wouldn’t be so powerful but…you get the point.

* Nights in Rodanthe (2008)

Starring: Richard GereDiane Lane

29d9v6o

Richard Gere and Diane Lane in Nights in Rodanthe

Actors are supposed to play all kinds of parts but let’s be honest, some actors do some roles better than others. And Richard Gere is great at drama- especially he is playing a romantic role. In Nights in Rodanthe, Richard plays a doctor named Paul. He is staying at the inn for a couple of nights. He is an unhappy man- he is being sued, his grown son doesn’t like him…

The only other person at the inn is Adrienne (Diane Lane), looking after the place for a friend. She is not having the time of her life either. Her husband has left for another woman now wants forgiveness, her daughter isn’t fond of her and her son has a condition…

They find it easy to get along, to open up to each other. They understand what being a parent is….They know about disappointments and mistakes. They truly see each other and they fall in love. It is the kind of romance that you dream about.

05060223_

nightsinrodanthee

nightsinrodanthemoviestill

And it is so easy to fall in love with Gere. 59 at the movie, he is still hot. Diane Lane is also naturally beautiful. You like them. You don’t want them to be apart. But Paul has to do one thing before they can be together in the long run- he has to go see his son, renconcile with him and help him with his patients.

nights-in-rodanthe-tsrimg1

Long distance doesn’t ruin things. To the contrary. It empowers their feelings. They are looking forward to meeting again. The day finally comes. But Paul doesn’t. The next day, the door bell rings and Adrienne gets to meet his son. He doesn’t have good news…

Yes, Sparks did it again. He took the lovely fantasy and took it away in the end.

How am I supposed to read his work- when I know there’s a 99% chance at least one main character will die? Where is the fun in that?

Share

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Twitter
  • RSS

8 Responses to “Reviews of 4 Nicholas Sparks Movie Adaptations: A Walk to Remember, Nights in Rodanthe, Message in a Bottle and The Notebook”

  1. Sophie says:

    What can I say? It is not nice to play with the feelings just to sell! Tragedy works, tears are powerful and heartache is guaranteed 🙂

  2. zoey says:

    I resent that:) I get unhappy endings all the time in real life. And unless you are going to make a masterpiece, stay away from making drama for drama’s sake! Did you see the other 3? I love them all individually but once you connect the dots, it is pretty annoying.
    And you can’t expect me to love the writer when he kills such great male characters. Especially not when they are played by Costner or Gere;)

  3. Sophie says:

    Yes I saw them all and I’m furious because I feel used. I never read this author and I never will. I like how you said it “drama for drama’s sake”. It’s stupid and annoying. My comment about The Notebook wasn’t for its beauty but for its laboratory mice’s path. At point one: two old people; at point two: memories; at point three: a view of the desease; at point four: sweet and melting youth love; at point five: those days are gone; at point six: goodmorning despair… and so on. Is like a precise pattern to suicide. It’s so easy to sell like that. Tears always work but you feel like you’re watching always the same movie…

  4. zoey says:

    Yeah it sucks. The formula is used in lots of tv shows as well. I never create drama just to create drama in my own stories.
    But, it might be girly but I do love male characters that are either misunderstood (Richard Gere’s) or bad boys that go good (Shane West’s in A Walk to Remember). Fantasy. Maybe less realistic than a futuristic sci-fi movie. But it is fun to watch nonetheless. Still, I will always like writers that write for fun and that want the audience to have fun…

    But sometimes dramas are so good, they feel natural. Have you seen The Painted Veil with Edward Norton and Naomi Watts? I adore that movie.

  5. Abdullah says:

    i’ve never seen such love stories.they have every power to melt a heart as strong as steel

  6. zoey says:

    I am not so sure about that. The author is too intent on making everyone cry that he forgets that the reason most people tune in to such stories is that they want the bad stuff in real life. So here you give them loves that seem to good to be true and then finish it off by killing at least one of the characters. That really seems like drama for drama’s sake rather than personal, inpiring or moving. But it is just me. By the way, I loved Message in a Bottle, A Walk to Remember and especially Nights in Rodanthe- right until teh very end.
    The notebook was better in the ending department but not good enough to set at least one different mood for one story…

  7. Mikee says:

    I love how the notebook ends. We’re all gonna die someday and i’d like to die with a person i love too 🙂

  8. zoey says:

    Well, their death was together and I can see how sweet it can sound but I’d rather they didn’t. Because it is not just The Notebook. Nicholas does this in every story and
    I just want to say, stop creating tragedies for tragedy’s sake..

Leave a Reply

*